Call the Police or File an Insurance Claim?
Five gates to decide fast after a personal-safety incident — and a printable checklist you can keep on hand. Educational use only; not legal advice.
The 5-gate go / no-go
Work top to bottom. The first "go" that applies tells you what to do.
- 1
Is there an immediate threat to life or safety right now?
Go → CALL 911 NOW. Get to safety and stay on the line. Life safety comes before any property or insurance step.
No-go → If no one is in danger, move to Gate 2 and use the non-emergency line later.
- 2
Did a crime just happen or is a suspect still nearby?
Go → CALL THE NON-EMERGENCY POLICE LINE and file a report. You will need the report number for most insurance claims.
No-go → If the incident is historical (e.g., a charge you just noticed), a 911 call is not appropriate — go to Gate 3.
- 3
Is there financial loss or property damage?
Go → You will most likely need a police report for the claim. File the report, then notify your insurer before any deadline.
No-go → If there is no loss, no report or claim is needed — see Gate 5 for fraud/identity cases.
- 4
Is this identity theft, fraud, or an online account takeover?
Go → File an FTC report at IdentityTheft.gov (and ReportFraud.ftc.gov for scams); notify banks/card issuers immediately. A local police report helps if identity was misused in person.
No-go → If it is ordinary property loss, skip straight to the insurer with your police report number.
- 5
Does your insurer require a report number or a filing window?
Go → Get the police/fire report number and file the claim within the deadline (commonly 24–72 hours for theft). Keep photos and receipts.
No-go → If loss is below your deductible, weigh whether a claim is worth it — but still document the incident.
Scenario quick reference
Common incidents and the usual path. Full detail, sources, and 15 scenarios are in the open dataset (CC BY 4.0).
- Break-in (no one home): non-emergency police report → insurer (needs report number).
- Intruder inside now: 911 → safety → report → insurer.
- Package theft: carrier + card-benefit claim first; police report optional.
- Car break-in: police report → auto comprehensive / renter claim.
- Identity theft: FTC IdentityTheft.gov report → banks → insurer fraud benefit.
- Fire / smoke: fire marshal report → insurer immediately.
- Assault / robbery: 911 if hurt/nearby → medical care → report → claims.
Plan ahead with SecurFig tools
Sources & license
Compiled from published U.S. insurer claims practice, the FTC (IdentityTheft.gov / ReportFraud.ftc.gov), and general emergency-services convention. Not legal advice — confirm with your insurer, local police non-emergency line, or an attorney.
Open dataset: personal-safety-scenarios-2026.json — licensed CC BY 4.0.